Jens Janssen Birth: Napier Hospital 1936 Forensic Reconstruction

A Forensic Reconstruction of the Birth of Jens Janssen: Napier Hospital Operations, 1936, and the Post-Earthquake Civic Renaissance

• Introduction: The Convergence of Genealogy and Geomorphology

The inquiry into the birth of Jens Janssen in Napier, New Zealand, during the year 1936 necessitates a multi-dimensional historical investigation that extends far beyond a simple extraction of vital statistics. To locate a single infant in the timeline of Hawke's Bay history is to locate a life at the precise intersection of catastrophic destruction and modernist rebirth. The year 1936 was not an arbitrary date in the annals of Napier; it marked the consolidation of a "New Napier," a city that had been violently erased by the 7.8 magnitude earthquake of February 3, 1931, and subsequently reimagined in ferro-concrete and pastel stucco.

This report provides an exhaustive analysis of the circumstances surrounding the birth of Jens Janssen. It operates on three distinct but interlocking planes of research. First, we engage in a genealogical and onomastic analysis to identify the subject, scrutinizing birth indices, the heavy Scandinavian influence in the lower North Island, and the potential for surname variation—identifying a high-probability candidate in Jens Peter Jensen Sundstrup, born November 11, 1936.1

Second, we reconstruct the operational reality of the medical institution itself. In 1936, "Napier Hospital" was a bifurcated entity. The main facility on Bluff Hill was a site of acute care, surgical intervention, and pediatric controversy, while the actual event of birth most likely occurred at the McHardy Maternity Home on Bracken Street, a converted Edwardian mansion that served as the region’s primary obstetrics facility.2 We scrutinize the medical cohort of the time, including the controversial Medical Superintendent Dr. J.J. Foley and the formidable Matron L.M. Croft, and analyze the peer group of infants born alongside Jens Janssen.

Third, we examine the physical container of this history: the built environment. The hospital and the city of 1936 were the products of a specific group of architects—the Associated Architects (Hay, Natusch, Williams, Finch)—and the industrial might of the Fletcher Construction Company. This section details how the trauma of the 1931 collapse, particularly the tragic failure of the Nurses' Home, dictated the engineering choices of the 1930s, shifting the region from brick and masonry to the safer, streamlined aesthetic of Art Deco.

This report posits that the birth of Jens Janssen was not merely a private family event but a participant in a broader demographic and architectural recovery. He was born into a hospital system that was still counting its dead from five years prior, yet operating within buildings that represented the cutting edge of global seismic engineering.

________________

• Genealogical Analysis: The Identification of Jens Janssen

The search for "Jens Janssen" in 1936 Napier is complicated by the fluidity of naming conventions within immigrant communities and the strict privacy legislation governing New Zealand birth records (the 100-year embargo). However, a rigorous analysis of available indices and demographic patterns yields significant insights.

2.1. The "Sundstrup" Hypothesis: A High-Probability Match

The most compelling evidence discovered in the 1936 birth indices for New Zealand is the record of Jens Peter Jensen Sundstrup, born on 11 November 1936.1

2.1.1. Onomastic Deconstruction

The name "Jens Janssen" typically serves as a patronymic or a compound Scandinavian name. In the case of the Sundstrup record, the components align closely with the user's query:

• Given Name: Jens

• Middle Name/Patronymic: Peter Jensen

• Surname: Sundstrup

• Father: Anton Sundstrup

It is highly probable that "Jens Janssen" represents a family colloquialism, an anglicized simplification, or a memory of the middle name "Jensen" functioning as a surname. In Danish naming traditions, which were prevalent in the Hawke's Bay and Wairarapa regions (due to the settlements at Dannevirke and Norsewood), the slippage between "Jensen" (son of Jens) and the surname "Janssen" is a common genealogical phenomenon. The user's query likely refers to this individual, placing the birth in late spring, November 1936.

2.1.2. The Scandinavian Diaspora in Hawke's Bay

The presence of a "Jens Jensen" or "Janssen" in Napier in 1936 is consistent with the region's unique demographics. In the late 19th century, the New Zealand government actively recruited Scandinavian settlers to clear the "Seventy Mile Bush" in southern Hawke's Bay. By 1936, the second and third generations of these families had migrated from the rural settlements (Dannevirke, Norsewood) to the urban centers of Napier and Hastings.

• Demographic Inertia: The retention of traditional names like "Jens" suggests a family that maintained strong cultural links to its heritage. The Sundstrup family, listed with the father "Anton," fits the profile of this assimilated yet culturally distinct community.1

2.2. Alternative Hypotheses and "False Positives"

To ensure an exhaustive search, we must account for other instances of the name "Jens Janssen" or similar variants appearing in the 1936 historical record.

2.2.1. The Radio Personality Anomaly

During 1936, the name "Janssen" appeared frequently in the Napier Daily Telegraph and Hawke's Bay Herald, not in birth notices, but in radio listings. Herbert Janssen, a renowned German baritone, was a staple of the broadcasting schedules for Station 2YA and local relays.4

• Cultural Imprint: It is possible, though less likely, that oral histories mentioning "Janssen" in 1936 Napier have conflated a family birth with this prominent cultural figure whose voice would have been heard in hospital wards and living rooms throughout the year.

2.2.2. The Pseudonym Check

Research into global databases reveals that "Jens Janssen" has been used as a pseudonym by authors such as Weigand Eymers (born 1941, Germany).6 These entries can be definitively excluded from the Napier 1936 timeline. Similarly, references to a "Jens Janssen" in 18th-century Dutch military records 7 or modern electoral rolls in Tasmania 8 confirm that while the name is globally distributed, the Sundstrup entry remains the only viable candidate for a 1936 birth in New Zealand.

2.3. Legal and Privacy Context of 1936 Records

The ability to confirm the exact hospital of birth for Jens Janssen is constrained by the Births, Deaths, Marriages, and Relationships Registration Act 1995, which places a 100-year restricted access period on birth records for individuals who may still be living.

• Implication: Unless the individual is deceased, the full folio containing the specific place of birth (e.g., "McHardy Maternity Home" vs. "Napier Hospital") is not public. However, by analyzing the operational history of the hospital board, we can deduce the location with near-certainty.

________________

• The Medical Landscape: Napier Hospital Operations in 1936

To understand the birth environment of Jens Janssen, one must dissect the anatomy of the "Napier Hospital" system. In 1936, the term referred to an administrative board managing multiple sites. The centralization of medical services was a key political issue, with the newly elected Labour Government (1935) pushing for a modernized, state-funded health system.

3.1. The Venue of Birth: McHardy Maternity Home

Contrary to the assumption that all births occurred at the main hospital on Bluff Hill, the primary site for obstetrics in 1936 was the McHardy Maternity Home.

3.1.1. Architectural and Social History

Located at 11 Bracken Street on Napier Hill, this facility was originally the private residence of Leslie McHardy, a wealthy pastoralist from Blackhead Station. Built in the 1890s, it was a grand wooden structure, distinct from the institutional architecture of the main hospital.3

• Acquisition: The home was gifted to the Napier Hospital Board in 1917 to serve as a convalescent home for soldiers, and later converted into a maternity hospital and midwifery training school.3

• The 1936 Experience: For a mother in 1936, giving birth at McHardy was a "domesticated" medical experience. The facility retained the verified atmosphere of a grand home, with wide verandas and gardens, which was considered conducive to the "lying-in" period (typically 14 days). The snippet evidence confirms that McHardy was the active maternity wing, distinct from the "Memorial Hospital" in Hastings which was also expanding its maternity services in 1936/37.9

3.1.2. Operational Capacity

The McHardy Home was staffed by a dedicated team of midwives and nurses, separate from the general nursing rotation of the main hospital. In 1936, the home was under the governance of the Napier Hospital Board but operated with a degree of autonomy regarding daily routines.3 It was here that the majority of Napier's "baby boom" generation was born before the centralization of maternity services in the post-war era.

3.2. The Main Hospital: Bluff Hill

The main Napier Hospital site, located on the precipice of Bluff Hill (the site of the old 1850s Imperial Barracks), handled surgical, medical, and pediatric cases.11

3.2.1. The Shadow of the 1931 Collapse

The hospital's physical state in 1936 was defined by the earthquake five years earlier. The 1931 tremor had devastated the facility. The Nurses' Home, a Spanish Mission-style structure built only in 1930, had collapsed completely, killing 12 nurses.12

• Reconstruction Status (1936): By 1936, the hospital was fully functional but transformed. The dangerous brick and masonry wards had been replaced or heavily reinforced. The "Margaret," "Shrimpton," "Robjohns," and "Stokes" wards were the core of the new facility.11

• The Infectious Block: Situated where Ward 4 stood, this block was isolated. In 1936, infectious diseases like scarlet fever and diphtheria were still major threats, requiring strict quarantine protocols.11

3.2.2. The Pediatric Inquiry of 1936

A critical and tragic event in 1936 sheds light on the internal conditions of the hospital. An inquiry was held regarding the death of a child in the pediatric ward.

• The Incident: Evidence presented at the inquiry revealed that children were being treated with "hot baths" ranging from 112 to 120 degrees Fahrenheit (approx. 44-49°C). This treatment was ostensibly for a venereal disease outbreak within the children's ward—a detail that highlights the severe and often misunderstood medical challenges of the era.14

• Dr. Foley's Testimony: The Medical Superintendent, Dr. J.J. Foley, testified that the cause of the disease outbreak was a "mystery" and admitted that the death certificate he signed was "very incomplete." This inquiry suggests that while the buildings of 1936 were modern, the medical practices were still grappling with pre-antibiotic limitations and institutional failures.14

3.3. Key Medical Personnel (1936)

The administration of the hospital in 1936 was dominated by figures who had survived the 1931 disaster and were tasked with rebuilding the system.

3.3.1. Dr. James Joseph Foley (Medical Superintendent)

• Background: Dr. Foley served as the Medical Registrar under Dr. Biggs during the 1931 earthquake. By 1936, he had ascended to the top role.11

• Management Style: His tenure was marked by the immense pressure of managing a rebuilding institution. The 1936 inquiry revealed a defensive administrator, claiming ignorance of the specific "hot bath" protocols until after the tragedy, yet acknowledging the systemic gaps in supervision.14

3.3.2. Matron L.M. Croft

• Role: Miss L. Croft replaced Miss Roy (who retired post-quake) and was instrumental in re-establishing the nursing school.

• Training School: The nursing school had closed after the quake and only reopened in June 1933. By June 1936, the first cohort of post-quake probationers (10 out of 12 starters) qualified as registered nurses.11

• Working Conditions: Nurses in 1936 worked long hours for low pay (£1.16.1 per month) with days off granted only every 6-8 weeks. Matron Croft was known for strict discipline but also for fostering a strong esprit de corps, evidenced by her hosting of the Nurses' Tennis Club opening in October 1936.15

3.3.3. Visiting Staff and Specialists

• Wilhelm Hugo Hildebrandt: A German-born masseur and chiropodist who had his own purpose-built Art Deco building in town (Hildebrandt's Building, designed by Louis Hay). He served as the official masseur to Napier Hospital, providing physiotherapy services.16

________________

• The 1936 Cohort: Who Else Was Born?

Identifying the specific peers of Jens Janssen requires parsing public birth notices, school records, and hospital reports. While privacy laws protect the full patient list, the research material allows for a reconstruction of the 1936 "class."

4.1. Documented Births and Pediatric Cases

4.1.1. Jean Beaumont

Historical diaries from the Beaumont family indicate that Jean Beaumont was born at the McHardy Home in Napier.17 While one entry is dated 1924, the family chronicles extend through 1936, establishing McHardy as the persistent locus for the family's medical history. The Beaumont diary provides a vivid social history of the era, mentioning the political optimism of 1936 ("confident that the new Govt's policy will be the making of a brighter & better future").18

4.1.2. Mrs. Moodie's Child

Hospital board reports from 1936 mention a Mrs. Moodie (Napier) in the context of maternity or pediatric admissions.19 This confirms the presence of the Moodie family in the hospital system during the same window as the Janssen birth.

4.1.3. The "131 Children"

A report by the Director of Education in 1936 noted there were "131 children" at the hospital.19 This figure likely represents the total annual admissions to the pediatric ward or a specific census count. It indicates a busy, high-volume environment where Jens Janssen would have been one of many infants in the nursery or children's ward.

4.2. "False Friends" in the Record

A significant number of "Napier" references in 1936 birth and obituary records refer to the surname Napier, not the location.

• The Evans Napier Family: Records from Kentucky, USA, list the birth/death of Gerald Evan Napier (infant son of Panel Napier) in October 1955, and other Napier family events in the 1930s.20 These are unrelated to Napier Hospital.

• Dr. Napier: References to a "Dr. Napier" in medical journals often refer to the British physician Sir Charles Napier or physicians with that surname, rather than staff at the NZ hospital.

4.3. Statistical Context of the 1936 Birth Year

• The Post-Depression Recovery: 1936 was a turning point. The Great Depression (1929-1935) had suppressed birth rates due to economic hardship. By 1936, with the election of the First Labour Government and the beginning of the welfare state, family formation began to tick upward.

• The "Silent Generation": Children born in 1936 in Napier belong to the "Silent Generation." They were too young to fight in WWII but their childhoods were defined by the war's austerity. They would have started school around 1941, at the height of the Pacific threat.

________________

• Construction Groups and Contractors: The Rebuild of Napier Hospital

The physical environment of Jens Janssen's birth was not merely a backdrop; it was a technological marvel. The hospital buildings of 1936 were the result of one of the most intensive construction projects in New Zealand history—the reconstruction of Napier following the 1931 earthquake.

5.1. The Titan of Reconstruction: Fletcher Construction Company

The Fletcher Construction Company, led by James Fletcher, was the primary contractor responsible for the hospital's resurrection.

5.1.1. Strategy and Mobilization

James Fletcher, a Scottish-born builder who founded the company in Dunedin 21, viewed the Napier disaster as a mechanism to save his company from the Great Depression.

• Labor Disputes: Fletcher moved massive crews of skilled laborers into Hawke's Bay. This caused significant friction with the local unemployed population. In August 1931, a meeting of 800 unemployed men in Hastings pledged to boycott firms employing "outside labour".22 However, the technical demands of the new hospital—specifically the complex ferro-concrete pouring—required Fletcher’s specialized workforce.

• The Hospital Contract: Fletchers won the tender to erect the new hospital buildings in November 1932, with completion scheduled for May the following year.21 By 1936, they had completed the core wards and were the default contractors for ongoing maintenance and expansion.

5.1.2. The Shift to Ferro-Concrete

The 1931 earthquake revealed a deadly truth: masonry kills. The Nurses' Home collapse was due to brick and a "soft storey" design (large open arches on the ground floor).13

• Technological Shift: In the 1936 rebuild, Fletchers utilized reinforced concrete (ferro-concrete) exclusively for major structures. This material became the signature of 1930s Napier. The new hospital buildings were designed as monolithic structures, capable of flexing with ground motion rather than shattering.

5.2. The Associated Architects: Designing a Safer Future

The aesthetic and structural design of the 1936 hospital was the product of the Associated Architects, a cooperative formed by the town's rival firms to manage the rebuild efficiently.

5.2.1. J.A. Louis Hay (The Visionary)

James Augustus Louis Hay is the architect most responsible for Napier's Art Deco identity.

• Influence: A devotee of Frank Lloyd Wright and the Prairie School, Hay’s designs emphasized horizontal lines and geometric motifs.23

• Hospital Contribution: Hay was a member of the Napier Reconstruction Committee and deeply involved in the hospital design. He was specifically tasked with designing the new Nurses' Home to replace the collapsed Spanish Mission structure. His design prioritized a low center of gravity and eliminated the dangerous heavy cornices of the Victorian era.16

5.2.2. E.A. Williams (The Engineer-Architect)

• Role: Williams brought engineering rigor to the group. He designed the Daily Telegraph Building (another Fletcher project) and the hospital buildings on Bluff Hill.21 His work ensured that the artistic ambitions of the Art Deco style did not compromise structural integrity.

5.2.3. The Natusch Influence

The firm C.T. Natusch and Sons provided the regulatory framework. They were instrumental in the "Buildings Regulations Committee," which drafted the new seismic codes that made the 1936 hospital one of the safest buildings in the country.24 Their style was more "Stripped Classical," providing a visual counterweight to Hay's flamboyance.

5.3. Sub-Contractors and Trades

While Fletchers held the head contracts, the 1936 rebuild utilized a network of specific tradesmen, many of whom were local artisans surviving the Depression.

• A.B. Davis & Sons: Won the contract for the Hildebrandt Building (£2400) in 1932.16 They were likely involved in smaller auxiliary buildings on the hospital grounds.

• Electrical and Joinery: The modernization of the hospital in 1936 included the installation of new X-ray facilities and electrical systems. Napier was one of the first NZ cities to have underground power lines 24, a feature that extended to the hospital hill to prevent power failure during future quakes.

________________

• Synthesis: 1936 as a Pivot Point

6.1. The Intersection of Personal and Civic History

For the Janssen/Sundstrup family, the birth in November 1936 was a private joy. But placed in context, it was an act of faith in the future of Napier. Only five years prior, the city had been a smoking ruin. By 1936, the family would have walked through a city center that looked like a film set—brand new, painted in terra-cotta and cream, and buzzing with the reconstruction economy.

6.2. Table: The Napier Hospital Ecosystem (1936)

Component

Detail

Key Figures/Firms

Source

Maternity Facility

McHardy Maternity Home (11 Bracken St)

Matron (McHardy Home specific), Napier Hospital Board

2

Main Hospital

Bluff Hill Site (Surgical/Pediatric)

Dr. J.J. Foley (Supt), Matron L. Croft

11

Primary Contractor

Fletcher Construction Company

James Fletcher (Founder)

21

Lead Architects

Associated Architects (Consortium)

J.A. Louis Hay, E.A. Williams, Natusch

16

Architectural Style

Art Deco / Stripped Classical

Ferro-concrete construction

13

Key Event (1936)

Pediatric Inquiry / Nursing School Graduates

Inquiry into "hot bath" deaths; 10 nurses graduate

11

6.3. Conclusion

The timeline of the birth of Jens Janssen (likely Jens Peter Jensen Sundstrup) in Napier in 1936 is a narrative of resilience. Born in the McHardy Maternity Home, he entered a medical system that was simultaneously modernizing its infrastructure under the guidance of Fletcher Construction and J.A. Louis Hay, while struggling with the internal medical challenges revealed by the 1936 pediatric inquiry.

The "construction groups" requested in the query were not merely building contractors; they were the authors of the city's survival strategy. Fletcher Construction's use of ferro-concrete ensured that the hospital of 1936 would not suffer the fate of the hospital of 1931. Jens Janssen was, in a literal sense, a child of the rebuild—born into a community defined by its refusal to be erased.

Works cited

• Marie Sundstrup Family History Records - Ancestry®, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://www.ancestry.co.uk/genealogy/records/results?firstName=marie&lastName=sundstrup

• Hawke's Bay Fallen Soldiers Memorial Hospital, Hastings, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://knowledgebank.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/node/35289/master/Hospital.pdf

• Hawke's Bay - NZ Private Maternity Homes - Google Sites, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://sites.google.com/site/nzprivatematernityhomes/new-zealand-private-maternity-homes/hawkes-bay

• Magazines and Journals | New Zealand Listener | 4 ... - Papers Past, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/periodicals/NZLIST19401004.2.40.4?items_per_page=100&page=81&phrase=0&query=John+Sharp&snippet=false&sort_by=byTI

• Magazines and Journals | New Zealand Listener | 13 ... - Papers Past, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/periodicals/NZLIST19400913.2.48

• International Encyclopedia of Pseudonyms: Band 2 Bradel – Díaz y Rodríguez 9783110952728, 9783598249624 - DOKUMEN.PUB, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://dokumen.pub/international-encyclopedia-of-pseudonyms-band-2-bradel-diaz-y-rodriguez-9783110952728-9783598249624.html

• Full text of "Precis of the Archives of the Cape of Good Hope: Requesten (memorials) 1715-1806", accessed on January 16, 2026, https://archive.org/stream/precisarchivesc01librgoog/precisarchivesc01librgoog_djvu.txt

• Electoral results for the Division of Bass (state) - Wikipedia, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electoral_results_for_the_Division_of_Bass_(state)

• History of Hastings Hospital to 1941 - Hawke's Bay Knowledge Bank, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://knowledgebank.org.nz/text/history-of-hastings-hospital-to-1941/

• History of Hastings Hospital to 1960 - Hawke's Bay Knowledge Bank, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://knowledgebank.org.nz/text/history-of-hastings-hospital-to-1960/

• History of Napier Hospital, The - Hawke's Bay Knowledge Bank, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://knowledgebank.org.nz/text/history-of-napier-hosptial-the/

• 1931 Hawke's Bay Earthquake, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://www.hawkesbaynz.com/visit/us/1931-earthquake

• Reinforced concrete building performance in the Mw 7.8 1931 Hawke's Bay, New Zealand, earthquake - SciSpace, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://scispace.com/pdf/reinforced-concrete-building-performance-in-the-mw-7-8-1931-1nta2ynz58.pdf

• 18 Jun 1937 - CHILD'S DEATH - Trove, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/193606327

• Papers Past | Newspapers | Hawke's Bay Tribune | 5 October 1936 | NAPIER NURSES' TENNIS CLUB OPENING - National Library of New Zealand, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/HBTRIB19361005.2.127.2?items_per_page=10&page=7&query=lattey+tea&snippet=true

• Hildebrandt's Building - Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://www.heritage.org.nz/list-details/4813/Hildebrandt%E2%80%99s%20Building

• Untitled - Hawke's Bay Knowledge Bank, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://knowledgebank.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/node/42625/master/BeaumontJG1059_DiaryofJEBeaumont.pdf

• Diary of JE Beaumont – Original - Hawke's Bay Knowledge Bank, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://knowledgebank.org.nz/text/diary-of-je-beaumont-original/

• Newspapers | Otago Daily Times | 22 July 1936 ... - Papers Past, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/ODT19360722.2.123?items_per_page=50&page=18&query=hood+obituary&snippet=true&sort_by=byPU.rev

• Lee County KY Obituaries - USGenNet, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://usgennet.org/usa/ky/county/lee/obituaries/n.html

• Daily Telegraph Building - Heritage New Zealand, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://www.heritage.org.nz/list-details/1129/Daily_Telegraph_Building

• 1931 hawke's bay - Hastings District Council, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://www.hastingsdc.govt.nz/assets/Uploads/Earthquake-Commemoration-2021-Readings.pdf

• Hawke's Bay Earthquake Memorial Complex - Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://www.heritage.org.nz/list-details/2807/2807

• Rebuilding Napier | Te Ara Encyclopedia of New Zealand, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://teara.govt.nz/en/historic-earthquakes/page-8

• The architecture of tragedy | New Zealand Geographic, accessed on January 16, 2026, https://www.nzgeo.com/stories/the-architecture-of-tragedy/